Decisions and Orders

Alphabetical List

A

ADDERALL XR

Decisions – Board Orders

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

AIROMIR

Decisions – Board Order

  • Voluntary Compliance Undertaking, April 2007 (PDF)
  • Board Order - (PMPRB-06-D2-AIROMIR), May 14, 2007 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

APO-SALVENT

Decisions

  • Application for Leave to Intervene (ratiopharm Inc.) - (PMPRB-08-D1-APO-SALVENT), October 27, 2008 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Notice of Motion

APOTEX

Decisions – Board Order

  • Preliminary Motions - (PMPRB-08-D1-APOTEX), October 27, 2008 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

  • Notice of Application (PDF)

Notice of Motion

Top of page

B

BAXALTA CANADA CORPORATION

Top of page

C

CELGENE

  • For the decisions in the Celgene Corporation matter, please see Thalomid.

CONCERTA

Decisions – Board Order

  • Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - April 1, 2009 (PDF)
  • Board Order - (PMPRB-06-D1-CONCERTA), April 28, 2009 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

COPAXONE – 2013 (Redetermination)

Decisions – Board Order

Notice of Hearing (PDF), June 28, 2013

  • Abridged Amended Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (PDF)

COPAXONE – 2010 (Redetermination)

Decisions – Board Order

  • Judicial Review
    • Federal Court – (Justice Zinn) (2013 FC 448), April 30, 2013
    • Federal Court – Return of monies paid into the Consolidated Revenue Fund (Justice Zinn) (2013 FC 500), May 14, 2013
  • Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-2010-D3-Copaxone), February 23, 2012 (PDF)
  • Board Order - (PMPRB-2010-D3-Copaxone), February, 2012 (PDF)
  • Decision/Reasons (on Voluntary Compliance Undertaking – June 24, 2010) (PDF)
  • Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-2010-D1-COPAXONE), May 6, 2010 (PDF)

COPAXONE- 2008

Decisions – Board Order

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Top of page

D

DOVOBET

Decisions – Board Order

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Top of page

E

EVRA

Decisions – Board Order

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Top of page

F

FASTURTEC

Decisions – Board Order

Notice of Hearing

Top of page

G

GALDERMA CANADA INC.

Top of page

H

HABITROL

  • PMPRB-94-D2/HABITROL, October 24, 1994 (PDF)
  • Voluntary Compliance Undertaking, October 18, 1994 (PDF)
  • Federal Court of Appeal Order A-209-94, June 7, 1994 (PDF)
  • Federal Court of Appeal Reasons A-209-94, June 7, 1994 (PDF)
  • Federal Court Reasons (1994 CarswellNat 859), May 3, 1994 (PDF)
  • Federal Court Order (1994 CarswellNat 859), April 29, 1994 (PDF)
  • PMPRB-94-D1/HABITROL, February 1, 1994 (PDF)

Top of page

N

NEULASTA

Decisions – Board Order

  • Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - October 13, 2009 (PDF)
  • Board Order - (PMPRB-09-D1-NEULASTA), October 21, 2009 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

NICODERM

Decisions – Board Order

Abridged Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Top of page

P

PENLAC NAIL LACQUER

Decisions – Board Order

  • Board Order/Merits - (PMPRB-07-D2-PENLAC), January 31, 2011 (PDF)
  • Decision - (PMPRB-07-D2-PENLAC), January 31, 2011 (PDF)
  • Motion for Production and Leave to File Reply Evidence - Decision: (PMPRB-07-D1-PENLAC), August 20, 2008 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

PENTACEL

Decisions – Board Order

  • Board Order - (PMPRB-07-D6-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), June 14, 2012 (PDF)
  • Decision - (PMPRB-07-D6-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), June 14, 2012 (PDF)
  • Judicial Review
  • Board Order - (PMPRB07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), March 16, 2010 (PDF)
  • Decision on the Merits - (PMPRB-07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), as amended March 1, 2010 (PDF)
  • Decision on the Merits - (PMPRB-07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), December 21, 2009 (PDF)
  • Motion for an Order for Particulars - Decision - (PMPRB-07-D3-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), November 16, 2007 (PDF)
  • Motion for Production of Contracts - Decision - (PMPRB-07-D2-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), November 16, 2007 (PDF)
  • Decision - (PMPRB-07-D1- QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), July 27, 2007 (PDF)
  • Application for leave to intervene by GlaxoSmithKline Inc. (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Schedule of Events (Revised) (PDF)

Top of page

Q

QUADRACEL

Decisions – Board Order

  • Board Order - (PMPRB-07-D6-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), June 14, 2012 (PDF)
  • Decision - (PMPRB-07-D6-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), June 14, 2012 (PDF)
  • Judicial Review
  • Board Order - (PMPRB07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), March 16, 2010 (PDF)
  • Decision on the Merits - (PMPRB-07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), as amended March 1, 2010 (PDF)
  • Decision on the Merits - (PMPRB-07-D5-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), December 21, 2009 (PDF)
  • Motion for an Order for Particulars - Decision - (PMPRB-07-D3-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), November 16, 2007 (PDF)
  • Motion for Production of Contracts - Decision - (PMPRB-07-D2-QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), November 16, 2007 (PDF)
  • Decision - (PMPRB-07-D1- QUADRACEL and PENTACEL), July 27, 2007 (PDF)
  • Application for leave to intervene by GlaxoSmithKline Inc. (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Schedule of Events (Revised) (PDF)

Top of page

R

RATIOPHARM INC.

Decisions – Board Order

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

RATIO-SALBUTAMOL HFA

Decisions – Board Order

  • Board Order - (PMPRB-08-D4-ratio-Salbutamol HFA), December 19, 2011 (PDF)
  • Board Order - (PMPRB-08-D3-ratio-Salbutamol HFA), October 17, 2011 (PDF)
  • Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-08-D3-ratio-Salbutamol HFA), May 27, 2011 (PDF)
  • Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-08-D2-ratio-Salbutamol HFA) - Preliminary Motions May 2009 - August 14, 2009 (PDF)
  • Board Order - (PMPRB-08-D2-ratio-Salbutamol HFA) - Preliminary Motions May 2009 - August 14, 2009 (PDF)
  • Subpoena - (PMPRB-08-D2-ratio-Salbutamol HFA), August 14, 2009 (PDF)
  • Preliminary Motions - (PMPRB-08-D1-ratio-Salbutamol HFA), November 28, 2008 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

REMICADE

Voluntary Compliance Undertakings

Decisions – Board Order

  • Press Release (PDF)
  • Board Order (PDF)
  • Joint Submission (PDF)
  • D1 - Application for Leave to Intervene - February 17, 2003 (PDF)

Risperdal Consta

Decisions – Board Order

  • Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - June 1, 2007 (PDF)
  • Board Order - (PMPRB-06-D1-RISPERDAL CONSTA), June 4, 2007 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

  • Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (PDF)

Top of page

S

SANDOZ CANADA INC.

Decisions – Board Order

Decision on the publication, in full, of the August 1, 2012 Board Decision on the Merits, October 1, 2012 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

SOLIRIS

Decision - Board Order: September 27, 2017 (PDF - 440 kb)

  • Panel’s decision – Excess Revenue Payment: November 8, 2017 (PDF - 186 kb)

Notice of Hearing (PDF - 179 Kb)

  • Statement of Allegations of Board Staff (PDF - 27 Kb)
  • News Release
  • Request an Extension of the Deadline – February 6, 2015 (PDF – 35 Kb)
  • Request for an Extension to File the Response – February 10, 2015 (PDF – 229 Kb)
  • Notice of Appearance – February 11, 2015 (PDF – 42 Kb)
  • Order Regarding Scheduling – February 13, 2015 (PDF - 182 Kb)
  • Response: March 9, 2015 (PDF – 1,102 Kb)
  • Appearance by Minister: March 9, 2015 (PDF – 60 Kb)
  • Request an Extension of the Deadline: March 11, 2015 (PDF – 37.5 Kb)
  • Order Regarding Scheduling: March 13, 2015 (PDF – 181 Kb)
  • Note to Parties Regarding Notice and Service: March 13, 2015 (PDF – 179 Kb)
  • Request an Extension of the Deadline: March 17, 2015 (PDF – 108 Kb)
  • Objection to Amendment of Ministers' Appearance: March 20, 2015 (PDF – 620 Kb)
  • Order Regarding Scheduling: March 26, 2015 (PDF – 186 Kb)
  • Order Regarding Confidentiality: March 26, 2015 (PDF – 184 Kb)
  • Affidavit of Eric Lun: April 1, 2015 (PDF - 1 MB)
  • Amended Notice of Appearance: April 2, 2015 (PDF - 184 Kb)
  • Reply: April 10, 2015 (PDF - 412 Kb)
  • Order Regarding the Pre-Hearing Conference: May 1, 2015 (PDF - 125 Kb)
  • Motion for leave to intervene: May 12, 2015 (PDF - 370 Kb)
  • Motion for Interlocutory Relief: May 15, 2015 (PDF - 7 MB)
  • Written Submissions accompanying a Motion for Interlocutory Relief: May 22, 2015 (PDF - 1.7 MB)
  • Order Regarding Scheduling: May 26, 2015 (PDF -183 Kb)
  • Written Submissions on the Motion for Leave to Intervene: May 29, 2015 (PDF - 2.5 MB)
  • Respondent’s written submissions in response to motion to intervene: May 29, 2015 (PDF - 1.58 MB)
  • B.C. response to respondent’s Notice of Motion: June 5, 2015 (PDF - 2.27 MB)
  • Written submissions filed by CLHIA: June 5, 2015 (PDF - 244 kb)
  • Replies filed by the respondent
  • Order regarding particulars and regarding the calendar: June 23, 2015 (PDF - 183 kb)
  • Amended Notice of Appearance: June 26, 2015 (PDF - 325 kb)
  • Amended respondent’s response: July 17, 2015 (PDF - 3.18 MB)
  • Order regarding scheduling: August 5, 2015 (PDF - 782 kb)
  • Respondent’s motion pertaining to a conflict of interest: August 21, 2015 (PDF - 1.76 MB)
  • Respondent’s motion pertaining to the disclosure of documents: August 21, 2015 (PDF - 1.27 MB)
  • Respondent’s motion to strike portions of B.C. further amended notice of appearance: August 21, 2015 (PDF - 838 kb)
  • Affidavit of Anna Di Domenico: August 21, 2015 (PDF - 4.87 MB)
  • Amended reply: September 1, 2015 (PDF - 393 kb)
  • Written Representations of the Respondent: Alexion’s motion re: Conflicts of interest: September 2, 2015 (PDF - 2 MB)
  • Written Representations of the Respondent: Alexion’s motion re: Disclosure of documents: September 2, 2015 (PDF - 2 MB)
  • Written Submissions of the respondent: (Alexion’s Motion re: Strike Portions of the Further Amended Notice of Appearance Filed by the Minister of Health): September 2, 2015 (PDF - 3 MB)
  • Chairperson’s Motion for leave to intervene: September 8, 2015 (PDF - 1 MB)
  • ALEXION'S WRITTEN REPRESENTATIONS (Board Staffs Motion to Strike Paragraphs 37 and 38 of the Amended Response and Alexion's Motion to Strike Paragraph 7 and the Amended Portion of Paragraph 9 of the Amended Reply): September 9, 2015 (PDF - 2 MB)
  • Written Representations of Board Staff in response to Alexion’s motion re: conflict of interest relating to Mary Catherine Lindberg: September 11, 2015 (PDF - 394 kb)
  • Written Representations of Board Staff (alleged conflict of Isabel Jaen Raasch): September 11, 2015 (PDF - 718 kb)
  • Responding Motion Record of Board Staff (Alleged Conflict of Isabel Jaen Raasch) : September 11, 2015 (PDF - 382 kb)
  • Written submissions, responding to Alexion’s conflict of interest motion by counsel for Mary Catherine Lindberg: September 14, 2015 (PDF - 390 kb)
  • Supplementary Written Representations of the Respondent in response to the Chairperson’s submissions: September 15, 2015 (PDF - 1.39 MB)
  • Board Decision – Motion Relating to Conflicts of Interest: October 5, 2015 (PDF - 241 kb)
  • Response of the Minister of Health of B.C. (Motion of the Respondent to strike portions of the Further Amended Notice of Appearance of the Minister of Health of B.C.): October 19, 2015 (PDF - 446 kb)
  • Response of Board Staff (Motion of the Respondent to strike portions of the amended reply of Board Staff): October 19, 2015 (PDF - 4.30 MB)
  • Response of Board Staff (Motion of the Respondent to strike portions of the further Amended Notice of Appearance of the Minister of Health of B.C.): October 19, 2015 (PDF - 5.14 MB)
  • Reply of Board Staff (Motion of Board Staff to strike portions of the Amended Response of the Respondent): October 19, 2015 (PDF - 4.44 MB)
  • Response of Board Staff (Motion of the Respondent for disclosure): October 19, 2015 (PDF - 2.66 MB)
  • Reply of the respondent (motion to strike portions of the Minister of Health of B.C.’s further amended notice of appearance): October 23, 2015 (PDF - 1.71 MB)
  • Reply of the Respondent (motion to strike portions of the amended reply of Board Staff): October 23, 2015 (PDF - 1.35 MB)
  • Reply of the Respondent (motion for disclosure): October 23, 2015 (PDF - 994 kb)
  • Further written submissions of the Respondent (Board Staff's Motion to Strike Paragraphs 37 and 38 of the Amended Response): October 23, 2015 (PDF - 502 kb)
  • Board Decision – Various Motions Related to Procedural Matters: November 24, 2015 (PDF - 177 kb)
  • Surreply of the Respondent: December 4, 2015 (PDF - 687 kb)
  • Scheduling order of the Board: December 7, 2015 (PDF - 90 kb)
  • Notice of Motion of the Respondent to Strike Evidence as Inadmissible: February 26, 2016 (PDF - 1.05 MB)
  • Written representations of the Respondent pertaining to the Motion to Strike Evidence as Inadmissible: March 8, 2016 (PDF - 1.98 MB)
  • Written representations of Board Staff pertaining to the Motion to Strike Evidence as Inadmissible: March 8, 2016 (PDF - 12.4 MB)
  • Reply of the Respondent pertaining to the Motion to Strike Evidence as Inadmissible: March 16, 2016 (PDF - 3.07 MB)
  • Board Decision – Motion to Strike Evidence as Inadmissible: March 29, 2016 (PDF - 217 kb)
  • Biotecanada Motion for Leave to Intervene: May 18, 2016 (PDF - 4 mb)
  • Request by Board Staff to amend the Statement of Allegations and to strike out portions of Barry Katsof's testimony: May 20, 2016 (PDF - 216 KB)
  • Panel order with regards to the Biotecanada motion for leave to intervene: May 30, 2016 (PDF - 182 KB)
  • Motion to Amend Statement of Allegations and Strike Certain Portions of Will-Say Statement: June 10, 2016 (PDF - 96 ko)
  • Order regarding scheduling: July 20, 2016 (PDF - 47 ko)
  • Alexion's supplementary response to board staff's amended statement of allegations: July 29, 2016 (PDF - 1.3 mb)
  • Supplementary reply of Board Staff to the Amended Statement of Allegations: August 11, 2016 (PDF - 1.53 MB)
  • BIOTECanada submissions: June 15, 2016 (PDF - 1.67 MB) 
  • Second motion of BIOTECanada to intervene: December 20, 2016 (PDF - 5.60 MB) 
  • Motion for Particulars of the Respondent: December 23, 2016 (PDF - 1.29 MB) 
  • Order of the Panel regarding the respondent’s motion for particulars: January 4, 2017 (PDF - 76 kb) 
  • Motion of the Respondent for an order permitting a witness to testify by videoconference: January 10, 2017 (PDF - 1.37 MB) 
  • Motion of the Respondent to preclude Board Staff from entering into evidence IMS data: January 13, 2017 (PDF - 724 kb) 
  • Motion of the Respondent with regard to the constitution of the Panel: January 13, 2017 (PDF - 28 kb) 
  • Order of the Panel regarding BIOTEcanada second motion for intervention: January 18, 2017 (PDF - 62 kb) 
  • BIOTECANADA’s Written Representations on the Merits: January 19, 2017 (PDF - 2.55 MB)
  • Motion of Board Staff for the production of documents: January 20, 2017 (PDF - 3.25 MB) 
  • Motion of the Respondent for the production of documents: January 23, 2017 (PDF - 33 kb) 
  • Order of the Panel on the Respondent’s motion for production: January 24, 2017 (PDF - 70 kb) 
  • Order of the Panel on Board Staff’s motion for production: January 24, 2017 (PDF - 63 kb) 
  • Order of the Panel regarding confidentiality: February 1, 2017 (PDF - 78 kb) 
  • Order of the Panel regarding the constitution of the Panel: February 1, 2017 (PDF - 111 kb) 
  • Notice of Motion and Written Representations of Board Staff: January 20, 2017 (PDF - 3.80 MB)
  • Response to Board Staff's Motion and Written Representations of the Respondent: January 23, 2017 (PDF - 20 kb)
  • Reply of Board Staff to the Response of the Respondent: January 23, 2017 (PDF - 261 kb)
  • Motions to Issue Subpeonas (Reasons for decision): January 24, 2017 (PDF - 63 kb)
  • Redacted Board Staff Written Submissions: March 24, 2017 (PDF - 1.66 MB)
  • Redacted British Columbia Written Submissions: March 31, 2017 (PDF - 163 kb)
  • CLHIA Written Submissions: March 31, 2017 (PDF - 81.9 kb)
  • Redacted Respondent 's Reply to BC Ministry and CLHIA: April 7, 2017 (PDF - 134 kb)
  • Redacted Respondent Written Submissions: April 7, 2017 (PDF - 1.23 MB)
  • Order Regarding Additional Confidentiality Claims and Admissibility of Certain Expert Reports: November 27, 2017 (PDF - 286 kb)
    • Schedule A to that Order: November 27, 2017 (PDF - 101 kb)

STRATTERA

Decisions – Board Order

  • Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - February 2009 (PDF)
  • Decision - (PMPRB-06-D1-STRATTERA) (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Top of page

T

TACTUO

Decisions – Board Order

  • Board Order - (PMPRB-12-D1-TACTUO), April 24, 2013 (PDF)
  • Voluntary Compliance Undertaking (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

THALOMID

Decisions – Board Order

Top of page

V

VIRAZOLE

Decisions – Board Order

  • Decision - Variation Order - (PMPRB-95-D6/VIRAZOLE), March 31, 2000 (PDF)
  • Variation Order - (PMPRB-95-D6/VIRAZOLE), March 29, 2000 (PDF)
  • Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-95-D5/VIRAZOLE), July 26, 1996 (PDF)
  • Decision/Reasons - (PMPRB-95-D2/VIRAZOLE), November 30, 1995 (PDF)

Top of page

Z

ZEMPLAR

Decisions – Board Order

  • Voluntary Compliance Undertaking - September 17, 2007 (PDF)
  • Board Order - (PMPRB-07-D1-ZEMPLAR), September 19, 2007 (PDF)

Notice of Hearing (PDF)

Date modified: